| Year | All-Stars (Position) |
|---|---|
| 2016 | Francisco Lindor, SS; Danny Salazar, P; Corey Kluber, P |
| 2015 | Jason Kipnis, 2B |
| 2014 | Michael Brantley, OF |
| 2013 | Jason Kipnis, 2B; Justin Masterson, P |
| 2012 | Asdrubal Cabrera, SS; Chris Perez, P |
| 2011 | Asdrubal Cabrera, SS; Chris Perez, P |
| 2010 | Roberto Hernandez, P |
| 2009 | Victor Martinez, C |
| 2008 | Cliff Lee, P; Grady Sizemore, OF |
| 2007 | C.C. Sabathia, P; Victor Martinez, C; Grady Sizemore, OF |
| 2006 | Grady Sizemore, OF |
| 2005 | Bob Wickman, P |
| 2004 | Ronnie Belliard, 2B; Matt Lawton, OF; Victor Martinez, C; C.C. Sabathia, P; Jake Westbrook, P |
| 2003 | C.C. Sabathia, P |
| 2002 | Omar Vizquel, SS |
| 2001 | Juan Gonzalez, OF/DH; Roberto Alomar, 2B |
| 2000 | R. Alomar, 2B; Chuck Finley, P; Travis Fryman, 3B; Manny Ramirez |
| 1999 | Roberto Alomar, 2B; Kenny Lofton, OF; Charles Nagy, P; Manny Ramirez, OF; Jim Thome, 1B; Omar Vizquel, SS |
| 1998 | Sandy Alomar Jr., C; Bartolo Colon, P; Kenny Lofton, OF; Jim Thome, 1B; Manny Ramirez, OF; Omar Vizquel SS |
| 1997 | Sandy Alomar Jr., C; David Justice, OF; Jim Thome, 1B |
| 1996 | Albert Belle, OF; Kenny Lofton, OF; Sandy Alomar Jr., C; Jose Mesa, P; Charles Nagy, P |
| 1995 | Carlos Baerga, 2B; Albert Belle, OF; Kenny Lofton, OF; Dennis Martinez, P; Jose Mesa, P; Manny Ramirez OF |
| 1994 | Albert Belle, OF; Kenny Lofton, OF |
| 1993 | Carlos Baerga, IF; Albert Belle, OF |
| 1992 | S. Alomar Jr., C; Carlos Baerga, 2B; Charles Nagy, P |
| 1991 | Sandy Alomar Jr., C |
| 1990 | Sandy Alomar Jr., C; Doug Jones, P; Brook Jacoby 3B |
| 1989 | Greg Swindell, P; Doug Jones, P |
| 1988 | Doug Jones, P |
| 1987 | Pat Tabler, 1B/DH |
| 1986 | Brook Jacoby, 3B; Ken Schrom, P |
| 1985 | Bert Blyleven, P |
| 1984 | Andre Thornton, OF |
| 1983 | Rick Sutcliffe, P; Manny Trillo, 2B |
| 1982 | Toby Harrah, 3B; Andre Thornton OF |
| 1981 | Bo Diaz, C; Len Barker, p |
| 1980 | Jorge Orta, OF/DH |
| 1979 | Sid Monge, P |
| 1978 | Jim Kern, P |
| 1977 | Dennis Eckersley, P; Jim Kern, P |
| 1976 | Dave LaRoche, P |
| 1975 | George Hendrick, OF |
| 1974 | Gaylord Perry, P; George Hendrick, OF |
| 1973 | Buddy Bell, 3B |
| 1972 | Gaylord Perry, P |
| 1971 | Ray Fosse, C; Sam McDowell, P |
| 1970 | Ray Fosse, C; Sam McDowell, P |
| 1969 | Sam McDowell, P |
| 1968 | Joe Azcue, C; Sam McDowell, P; Luis Tiant, P |
| 1967 | Max Alvis, 3B; Steve Hargan, P |
| 1966 | Gary Bell, P; Rocky Colavito, OF; Sam McDowell, P; Sonny Siebert, P |
| 1965 | Rocky Calavito, OF; Max Alvis, 3B; Sam McDowell, P; Vic Davalillo, OF |
| 1964 | Jack Kralick, P |
| 1963 | Jim "Mudcat" Grant, P |
| 1962 | Dick Donovan, P; John Romano C |
| 1961 | Tito Francona, OF/1B; Barry Latman, P; Jim Perry, P; John Romano, C; Johnny Temple, 2B |
| 1960 | Gary Bell, P; Harvey Kuenn, OF; Vic Power, 1B; Dick Stigman, P |
| 1959 | Rocky Colavito, OF; Cal McLish P; Minnie Minoso, OF; Vic Power, 1B |
| 1958 | Ray Narleski, P; Mickey Vernon, 1B |
| 1957 | Don Mossi, P; Vic Wertz, 1B; Early Wynn P |
| 1956 | Herb Score, P; Ray Narleski, P; Early Wynn |
| 1955 | Bobby Avila, 2B; Larry Doby, OF; Al Rosen 3B; Herb Score, P; Al Smith, IF/OF; Early Wynn, P |
| 1954 | Bobby Avila, 2B; Larry Doby, OF; Mike Garcia, P; Bob Lemon, P; Al Rosen 3B |
| 1953 | Larry Doby, OF; Mike Garcia, P; Bob Lemon, P; Al Rosen, 3B |
| 1952 | Bobby Avila, 2B; Larry Doby, OF; Mike Garcia, P; Jim Hegan, C; Bob Lemon, P; Dale Mitchell, OF; Al Rosen 3B |
| 1951 | Jim Hegan, C; Bob Lemon, P; Larry Doby, OF |
| 1950 | Bob Feller, P; Bob Lemon, P; Jim Hegan, C; Larry Doby OF |
| 1949 | Bob Lemon, P; Jim Hegan. C; Larry Doby, OF; Joe Gordon 2B, Dale Mitchell OF |
| 1948 | Bob Feller, P; Bob Lemon P; Lou Boudreau SS; Joe Gordon 2B; Ken Keltner 3B |
| 1947 | Bob Feller, P; Jim Hegan C; Lou Boudreau, SS; Joe Gordon 2B |
| 1946 | Bob Feller, P; Frank Hayes C; Ken Keltner, 3B |
| 1945 | No Game |
| 1944 | Lou Boudrea, SS; Roy Cullenbine OF; Oris Hockett OF; Ken Keltner, 3B |
| 1943 | Jim Bagby Jr., P; Alfred Smith P; Lou Boudreau SS; Buddy Rosar, C; Ken Keltner, 3B; Jeff Heath OF |
| 1942 | Jim Bagby Jr., P; Lou Boudreau SS; Ken Keltner, 3B |
| 1941 | Bob Feller, P; Lou Boudreau SS; Ken Keltner, 3B; Jeff Heath OF |
| 1940 | Bob Feller, P; Rollie Hemsley C; Al Milnar P; Lou Boudreau, SS; Ken Keltner, 3B; Ray Mack 2B |
| 1939 | Bob Feller, P; Rollie Hemsley C |
| 1938 | Earl Averill, P; Mel Harder, P; Bob Feller |
| 1937 | Earl Averill, P; Mel Harder, P |
| 1936 | Earl Averill, P; Mel Harder, P |
| 1935 | Earl Averill, P; Mel Harder, P; Joe Vosmik OF |
| 1934 | Earl Averill, P; Mel Harder, P |
| 1933 | Wes Ferrell, P; Oral Hildebrand, P; Earl Averill, OF |
